The Hoffman House Bartender's Guide by Charles S. Mahoney (1905, p.230)

5 gallonsBourbon whiskey — Bourbonbase
0.5 ouncetincture of cardamom — tincture of cardamomsbitter
1 ouncetincture of gentian bitter
1 ouncetincture of lemon peel bitter
2 ouncestincture of orange peel bitter
2 gallonswater dilution
solferino and caramel — Solferino and caramelother
1 quartgum syrup sweetener
  1. Mix the Bourbon, water, gum syrup, tincture of orange peel, tincture of lemon peel, tincture of gentian, and tincture of cardamom thoroughly.
  2. Color with solferino and caramel in equal proportions.

See also: Bottle Cocktail, Whiskey Cocktail