The Buffet Blue Book by John H. Considine (1912, p.64)
| 0.5 jigger | Jamaica rum | base |
| 0.5 jigger | rye whiskey | base |
| 1 lump | sugar — cut lump sugar | base |
| 2 dashes | Abbott's Bitters | bitter |
| 2 dashes | orange bitters | bitter |
| seltzer — Dissolve sugar and dash on top. | dilution |
- Dissolve the cut lump sugar in a little seltzer in an old-fashioned whiskey glass, then add the bitters, Jamaica rum, and rye whiskey.
- Place a small spoon in the glass, dash on top with seltzer, and serve.