Cooling Cups and Dainty Drinks by William Terrington (1869, p.169) — Terrington 1869

1 bottleclaret base
1 bottleSoda water — soda-waterdilution
balm and borage other
sugar — To taste.sweetener
  1. Combine the claret and soda-water, sweeten to taste, and herb lightly with balm and borage.
  2. Ice up, but do not let the herbs remain in the drink for long.

Ice: Ice

This is a good witness to the very restrained end of the Victorian cup spectrum.

The drink's whole balance depends on avoiding over-herbing, which Terrington repeatedly flags as a danger.

See also: Oxford Claret Cup, Claret Cup a la Rawlings, Sherry Cup No. 3

Terrington explicitly warns not to let the herbs remain in long.