American and Other Drinks by Leo Engel (1878, p.24)

0.5 gallonbrandy base
0.5 gallonJamaica rum base
6 wholelemon — lemonsbase
1 pintmilk dilution
1.75 quartwater dilution
1 poundsugar — white sugarsweetener
  1. Steep the lemons for twenty-four hours in the brandy and rum, add the sugar, water, and milk, then strain through a jelly bag.

Ice: Optional

For a party of twenty. May be used either hot or cold.