American and Other Drinks by Charlie Paul (1884, p.16)
| lemon peel — Inherited from Brandy Cocktail. | acid | |
| dash | Angostura bitters — angostura bitters | base |
| 0.5 | rye whiskey — Substitutes for Bourbon whiskey. | base |
| dash | plain syrup — Inherited from Brandy Cocktail. | sweetener |
- Prepare as for the Bourbon Cocktail, using Rye whiskey in place of Bourbon whiskey.
Garnish: Lemon peel
Ice: Chipped ice