Bartender's Manual by Theodore Proulx (1888, p.41) — Theodore Proulx 1888

Lemon juice (fresh) — lemon juiceacid
simple syrup — syrupbase
1 jiggerSt. Croix rum base
Seasonal fruit — fruitsgarnish
0.5 ponyCuracao liqueur — curacoamodifier
ice — iceother
Straws — strawsother
  1. Put punch-style syrup and lemon juice into a cobbler glass with the curacoa and rum.
  2. Fill with ice and serve with straws and fruit.

Garnish: Seasonal fruit

Ice: Ice

Summary
A rum-and-curacoa cobbler-edge drink preserving an ornate tropical-adjacent service line.

White Lyon matters because it shows how much overlap still existed between punch, cobbler, and named cocktail worlds in 1888.

Its cobbler-glass fruit-and-straw service matters as much as the split-base formula.

Compared with Knickerbocker, this is less red-fruit shaped and more curacoa-rum forward.

See also: Knickerbocker, Curacao Punch, Whiskey Crusta