Family

Drinks a La Mode by Mrs de Salis (1891, p.25) — Drinks a La Mode 1891

2 tablespoonlemon juice — Strained.base
1 good gillrum base
4 tumblerfulwater — cold waterdilution
4 tablespooncaster sugar — castor sugarsweetener
  1. Blend lemon juice and sugar, add cold water, dissolve the sugar, then add rum and serve at once.

The American Bar-Tender by R. C. Miller (1895, p.33) — R. C. Miller 1895

0.5 pintbrandy — brandybase
13 wholelemon — lemonsbase
0.5 pintrum — rumbase
2 quartwater — waterdilution
5 wholeOrange — orangegarnish
1 bottleorange shrub — orange or lemon shrubmodifier
6 glassCalf's-foot jelly — calf's-foot jellyother
1 pintclarified syrup — clarified syrupsweetener
sugar — sugarsweetener
  1. Rub the rind of three lemons on pieces of sugar and put the sugar into a jug.
  2. Add the thin rind of one lemon and one orange, and the juice of four oranges and ten lemons, with six glasses of dissolved calf's-foot jelly.
  3. Pour two quarts of water over the whole, mix well, cover the jug, and keep it on a warm hearth for twenty minutes.
  4. Strain the mixture.
  5. Add a pint of clarified syrup, half a pint each of rum and brandy, and a bottle of good orange or lemon shrub.
Nose
Citrus oils, jelly richness, shrub, and mixed spirits build a deep ceremonial punch aroma.
Palate
This is close kin to Oxford Punch, but the clarified syrup and shrub emphasis make it feel slightly more polished and bottled-sweetener driven.
Finish
The finish is long, sweet-citric, and richly integrated.
Summary
A grand citrus-jelly punch whose sweetness and perfume are shaped by clarified syrup and shrub.

Yorkshire Punch is another good example of the nineteenth-century taste for composited punches built from multiple preparation systems at once: sherbet logic, jelly, clarified syrup, shrub, and mixed spirits.

The staged warming and straining are important. This is a process drink built for integration, not a rapid-service mixture.

See also: Oxford Punch, Royal Punch, Punch a la Ford